Friday, February 11, 2011

Monument Analysis - Ross Bay Cemetery


Data Set
            While walking among the graves in Ross Bay Cemetery, we were all struck by the unique and non-traditional grave markers. In a sea of crosses and classic tombstones, it is a feat to make your grave marker stand out, and these people certainly managed to. It is difficult to define the parameters of this particular data set, given that their consistency is in their individuality; it is the markers which have no other equal within the cemetery.




View Ross Bay Cemetery in a larger map


Cluster 1: Monuments 7, 8, 9,  & 10
Cluster 2: Monuments 2, 3, 4, & 5
Cluster 3: Monuments 1& 11


Research Questions

1. Are there/is there a certain area(s) where the unique grave markers tend to congregate or do they follow a pattern? If so, do the markers within a congregation show similarities?

            Although our data set consists of non-traditional grave markers, there was consistency shown in the location of them. Of the eleven grave markers selected for the data set, all but one of them fit into one of three fairly distinct clusters throughout the cemetery. The tree stump (Norman Kirk), sundial (Graham Pettapiece), anchor (Elizabeth Schultz) and eagle (Frederick Layton and Barnard Erickson) are located in the Southwest region of the site (cluster 1). The Saint Clare statue, baby chair (D.B. Campbell), Pooley Angel and fireman’s hat (Fred Medley) are located in the Northeast corner (cluster 2). The Bossi angel and the Deans family monument are located on the Northern perimeter (cluster 3). The Behnsen monument is located on the Southern perimeter and is not situated near any other markers from the data set.
           
            Contrary to what one might expect, nearly all these grave markers have fairly early dates in both birth and death. It seems to be a common assumption that less traditional graves would be a more modern practice, however the earliest date of death is 1893 (Bossi) and a majority are before 1945. In cluster 3 both monuments are family plots, and have a human figure marking their graves. In cluster 2, we see two single graves of untimely deaths: the baby and the fireman, and two group plots. These two clusters contain all the large group and family plots within our data set (excluding Behnsen monument), and are located near the main entrance and walkway into the cemetery. This most likely suggests that these were fairly valuable plots during the opening/construction of the cemetery in 1873 and were purchased by the wealthy families of Victoria (Old Cemeteries Society Of Victoria, 2010). Cluster 1 and the single Behnsen monument are located on the Northern edge of the cemetery near the water and as one could infer from our previous data, the plots are for single person burials with the exception of the eagle (two people) and Behnsen monument. These sites are further away from the main entrance, however are along the water’s edge, which oddly enough is the area of the cemetery with the majority of unoccupied space. One would think this terrain would be quite desired, however the increased weathering and soil erosion problems in this section may explain the single person plots, as they would be less expensive.

            This data shows that even in our attempts to stand out from the crowd, we as humans inevitably find ways to tie ourselves to one another. The unique grave markers within Ross Bay Cemetery are incredibly inspiring, and remind people that although we will all go one day, we will still be remembered.


2. Were these graves primarily for one person or multiple people? If they were designed for one person initially, how have the new additions affected the space?

            We did not find a significant difference in the number of graves with more than one person, six out of the eleven monuments surveyed marked the graves of more than one person. Only one of those eight graves is a pair of people, which was the eagle (relationship between the pair is unspecified). The names on the eagle monument both suggest to be male and have separate surnames; although the dates of birth are twenty-nine years apart, their deaths are only three years from one-another and the name plaques are significantly different in appearance. The difference is due to the three (or possibly more) extra years of weathering and eroding on the bronze plaques, as one now bears the tell-tale turquoise tinge of oxidation, giving the monument a somewhat disjointed look.

The four largest monuments ( Saint-Clare, Bossi Angel, Pooley Angel and Deans monument), which have human form statues all represent a group of multiple people. The size and stature of these monuments appear to be purposefully indicative of the scope of lives they accommodate. It is evident from the Pooley Angel with the range of materials and incsribed fonts, that the monument was originally built for Charles and the bodies (or perhaps only epitaphs) of his family were laid to rest after the monument was erected; all the available space to inscribe names at the base appears to be consumed (Adams, 1983).  The Behnsen monument seems to have been built at once, as each name has their own side and is evenly spaced on the marker. The epitaph style is also consistent across the monument, even though the dates of death are inconsistent. These observations indicate the monument was either erected after all the deaths occurred, or the remaining family members had their names inscribed before their deaths; and that it possibly only marks or contains ashes of the deceased.

            From the fieldwork and research, it became evident just how personal and symbolic these monuments are for the deceased and/or their families. Whether they waited to be buried together or were upholding tradition, these grave markers-though quirky and out of the ordinary-still represent family and love.



References

Old Cemeteries Society Of Victoria. (2010). Ross Bay Cemetery. Retrieved from http://www.oldcem.bc.ca/cem_rb.htm

Adams, J. (1983). Historic Guide To Ross Bay Cemetery. Victoria, BC: Sono Nis Press.

Monday, February 7, 2011

A Pirate's Burial For Me

Disneyland is one of the happiest places on earth, so it's no surprise that people wish to remain there forever; however the cleaning crew at the park isn't so thrilled with a new trend in burial practices, that although first occurred in the 1990s, has now become increasingly common within the gates of the Magic Kingdom. There are supposedly more human remains scattered in Disneyland than in any other theme park in the world, and this has become such a large issue for custodial staff, that special vacuums with HEPA filters have been purchased which remove human particles. The Haunted Mansion ride is fittingly, the most popular place for spreading ashes. For those of you who don't remember or have not been, this is when you ride in the cars through a cemetery and a ghost pops up beside you; not a popular ride for small children that are sitting next to Mum and Dad, who get replaced by this:

The "Small World" ride is also a hot spot for remains, which is a bit perplexing, but i do find the anthem for the ride rather creepy, so maybe I'm not the only one who thinks of it as an eerie location.
Pirates of the Caribbean is my favourite ride of all-time and since I'd like my ashes to be spread in water, this seems like a win-win situation for me. However I hope my relatives are a tad more cunning than one woman who recently decided to spread the ashes of her beloved throughout the 15 minute ride. After being caught on camera she was questioned afterwards and claimed that she had merely been "Throwing baby powder around", a usual occurrence there I am sure...

FYI: should you see someone spreading ashes you are supposed to call the custodial hotline and whisper (yes, whisper) "HEPA clean-up"



Monday, January 17, 2011

When I Go...


As creepy as it might sound, I’ve actually always known what I’d like to happen to me when I die. A coffin and grave really has never sounded appealing to me, and for me it seems more tragic than what I had envisioned. I would like to be cremated and have my ashes spread at the beach where I have spent most of my life.
I don’t exactly have words to describe my devotion and love towards the ocean, but can explain certain aspects of why I love it so dearly.
 My Nana has lived near a small bay in the Saanich Inlet since the early 1900s and the entire family has grown up there. It is the center of our family and always will be. When I was a baby I would bob around in a red swimsuit/innertube contraption for entire afternoons. I do remember being frustrated at not being able to go underwater and explore this new world I had discovered, but of course the sole purpose of the suit was to keep me from doing any such thing so attempts became meaningless. Then came boogie boards, which were my rock collecting devices. It is shocking there are even rocks still left on the beach after the many hours of scouring I did. They never looked nearly as pretty or shiny once they were dry, but I was content to mull about for hours in the shallows picking my favourites. 
My absolute favourite thing about the ocean though, is lying in the starfish position. Whether it’s twilight and the stars are just appearing or it’s the middle of the day and my little cousins are shouting at the dogs on the shore, when I tilt my head back and float, it’s as though everything ceases to exist. There is no sound, all you see is sky and you are weightless. Nothing I’ve come across in the world so far has ever compared to this feeling, and so the ocean is my sanctuary; where I go when I’m happy, upset or homesick.

On to actual things I’d want to come with me (wherever that may be)…My little red innertube would be one because of all that it represents. Books have always been (as I’m sure with most people) a sort of haven for me, and as juvenile as it sounds, my Harry Potter books are what I would want with me. Beginning in grade two when I first picked one up, I can honestly say that story has been the most constant thing in my life, only next to my family. There are a few pieces of jewellery I’ve collected on my travels that I would want to wear, including: a thin cord bracelet bought in Villefranche and a braided leather bracelet from Rome (possibly my favourite city). I would also need something to represent dance. Experiences I’ve had in dance, travelling, meeting people and creating incredible friendships have quite literally shaped me. However I honestly can’t think of one single thing to encapsulate all that. 
My personal belief is that it gives more closure if someone is laid to rest this way, perhaps because I’m so unfortunately sentimental, but if I am ash in the water people won’t have to walk past my grave. I won’t be tied to a fixed point where people have to visit. I also like the idea of travelling even after my death. I would be constantly moving and wherever I may end up, I will forever remain in my sanctuary.

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Hello

Hi guys, I'm Maddy. I'm a first year student and haven't declared a major yet, but anthropology has been an interest of mine for quite awhile. I chose to do this course because death is such a fascinating and mysterious subject, and the way different people approach it has always intrigued me. Whether a society welcomes or rejects death, the rituals surrounding it give us insight into their culture and tell a great deal about their lives. I was obsessed with Pharaoh's tombs in ancient Egypt as a kid, so this morbid fascination with death and archaeology was sparked at a young age.
People's beliefs surrounding death and the afterlife also allows you to see someone in an entirely different way. This combination of history and human nature is why I love anthropology, there is no other field with such an array of perspectives you get to see the world through.